PRESS RELEASE - Panama's Supreme Court Upholds Rights of Nature, Declares Country's Largest Copper Mine Unconstitutional
Panama City, Panama: On November 28, 2023, Panama’s Supreme Court unanimously ruled the Cobré Panamá copper mine unconstitutional, following weeks of nationwide protests. According to President Laurentino Cortizo, a process to close the mine will soon commence. The Court’s decision references the national Rights of Nature law, Law 287, passed in February 2022, among its rationale for ruling against the mine. The ruling represents a landmark victory for the burgeoning Rights of Nature movement, which seeks to recognize that Nature has basic rights under the law, just as humans do.
PANAMA’S SUPREME COURT UPHOLDS RIGHTS OF NATURE, DECLARES COUNTRY’S LARGEST COPPER MINE UNCONSTITUTIONAL
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: November 29, 2023
Contacts:
Juan Diego Vásquez Gutiérrez, Congressman - Panamanian Parliament (jvasquez@asamblea.gob.pa, +507 6980-6821)
Callie Annette Veelenturf, The Leatherback Project (callie@leatherbackproject.org, +1 (508) 315-9464)
Constanza Prieto Figleist, Earth Law Center (cfigelist@earthlaw.org, +1 (202) 621-3877)
Rachel Bustamante, Earth Law Center (rbustamante@earthlaw.org, +1 (240) 490-0219)
Panama City, Panama: On November 28, 2023, Panama’s Supreme Court unanimously ruled the Cobré Panamá copper mine unconstitutional, following weeks of nationwide protests. According to President Laurentino Cortizo, a process to close the mine will soon commence. The Court’s decision references the national Rights of Nature law, Law 287, passed in February 2022, among its rationale for ruling against the mine. The ruling represents a landmark victory for the burgeoning Rights of Nature movement, which seeks to recognize that Nature has basic rights under the law, just as humans do.
In a clear application of Panama’s Rights of Nature law, the court took an ecocentric perspective, reaffirming that Nature is a subject of rights, including ensuring Nature is protected, restored, and can regenerate its life cycles. In accordance with these rights, the court affirmed that the government of Panama is required to develop “necessary public policies to ensure ‘the highest interest of Nature,’ now for its intrinsic value, and regardless of the utilitarian value it has for human beings.” The court then determined that the mining contract did not meet these standards because it failed to include strict measures to prevent environmental damage.
Congressman Juan Diego Vásquez Gutiérrez, an independent politician who is the youngest Panamanian Congressperson, introduced the national Rights of Nature law to Panama's National Assembly. He said:
“I am very happy to have been part of a fundamental legal instrument to end the metal mining industry in the country. This is one of many tangible effects that we must repeat in defense of the environment thanks to legislation like this.“
The public outcry began in October following the government’s renegotiated contract with a Canadian mining company, First Quantam Minerals, that would have extended mining operations for the next 20 years in the biodiverse Colón Province near the Caribbean coast. Opponents claimed expanded exploration would further degrade coastal rainforests that supply freshwater to the region, harming the Indigenous population and endangered species including the Geminis’ poison dart frog (Andinobates geminisae) and several bird species.
When asked the significance of this ruling to the Rights of Nature movement, Callie Veelenturf, marine conservation biologist, National Geographic Explorer, and Founder of The Leatherback Project, who originally proposed the concept of a new Rights of Nature law in Panama to Congressman Juan Diego Vásquez, stated:
“The Supreme Court’s reference to Panama’s Rights of Nature law carries significant weight and exemplifies for the world a tangible example of how Rights of Nature laws, inspired and informed by science, can be used to protect Nature. I am exuding with hope for the future of nature conservation in Panama, including the implementation of Panama’s new sea turtle conservation Law 371, which also includes the recognition of the intrinsic rights of sea turtles. I greatly admire the indomitable people of Panama for defending Nature with such determination and persistence.”
This win for Rights of Nature implementation comes after a similar blocking of a copper mine earlier this year in Ecuador, where a provincial court ruled a mining project violated the constitutional Rights of Nature in the Intag Valley of the Tropical Andes. Additionally, in 2022, the Convention on Biological Diversity became the first international agreement to include the Rights of Nature, producing the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework as one approach to meeting the 23 action targets for biodiversity protection over the next decade. Panama’s recent ruling aligns with the biodiversity treaty’s objectives to reduce the loss of biodiverse areas (Target 1) and human induced extinction to threatened species (Target 4).
Constanza Prieto Figelist, Latin America Legal Director at Earth Law Center, which provided input and expertise on the Rights of Nature during the legislative drafting process, commented:
“This case demonstrates that under a Rights of Nature framework, governments must give stronger consideration to the health and intrinsic value of Nature when overseeing mining and other activities, elevating the interests of species and ecosystems to a higher status alongside human interests. The case also demonstrates that the Rights of Nature is an effective tool to protect the environment where traditional laws might fall short. We hope this will inspire other governments to give Nature a formal voice and rights in the legal system, as Panama did.”
Panama has become a world leader in the larger movement to recognize the Rights of Nature and was the third country to recognize the Rights of Nature on a national level. Globally, Rights of Nature is now recognized at some level of government in about 30 countries. For example, in 2008, Ecuador became the first country in the world to constitutionally recognize the Rights of Nature. Just this year, the rights of the Ocean or “Ocean Rights” was presented to the United Nations General Assembly, Spain recognized the Mar Menor saltwater lagoon as a legal entity with legal rights, and seven municipal and county governments in Washington State (USA) recognized the rights of the Southern Resident Orcas, an endangered species, in an important step toward protecting them and their habitat, the Salish Sea. Panama is expected to continue implementing the Rights of Nature in its legal system in the coming years.
The Leatherback Project (https://www.leatherbackproject.org) is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization dedicated to the conservation of the massive leatherback sea turtle throughout its global range through research, education and advocacy initiatives aimed at mitigating fisheries bycatch, reducing plastic pollution and combating climate change. While studying sea turtles in Panama, Founder and Executive Director of The Leatherback Project, Callie Veelenturf, originally brought the concept of Rights of Nature to Juan Diego Vasquez as a proposal for a new law.
Earth Law Center (www.earthlawcenter.org) is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization working to advance laws and policies that restore nature to health. They advocate for a transformation in our legal, governance, and economic systems, and the relationships, values, and ethics that create their foundation. Earth Law Center is a member of the United Nations’ Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) and the International Union for the Conservation of Nature, an expert and partner of the UN Harmony with Nature Initiative, and a member of the High Seas Alliance.
The Global Alliance is a world-wide movement of individuals and organizations creating human communities that respect and defend the rights of Nature.
Join us and get back to what really matters.
-
October 2024
- Oct 31, 2024 Victoria en segunda instancia: Sala Civil de Loreto ratifica sentencia que declara al río Marañón y sus afluentes como sujeto de derecho Oct 31, 2024
- Oct 31, 2024 Landmark Victory: Civil Court of Loreto Upholds Ruling Recognizing Rights of the Marañón River and Its Tributaries in Appellate Decision Oct 31, 2024
- Oct 2, 2024 New Report Champions Legal and Financial Support for Earth-Centered Laws and Governance Ahead of Biodiversity Negotiations in Cali, Colombia Oct 2, 2024
- August 2024
-
June 2024
- Jun 19, 2024 PR: Earth Law Portal Launch Jun 19, 2024
-
February 2024
- Feb 29, 2024 New Report from Earth Law Center Advocates for Ocean Justice in Global Plastics Treaty Feb 29, 2024
- November 2023
- May 2023
-
March 2023
- Mar 15, 2023 The Rights of Nature movement continues to grow in the Pacific Northwest Mar 15, 2023
- Mar 15, 2023 PANAMA PASSES NATIONAL SEA TURTLE LAW RECOGNIZING THEIR RIGHTS Mar 15, 2023
-
December 2022
- Dec 22, 2022 COP15: Landmark Biodiversity Deal Recognizes Rights of Nature is Vital to its Success Dec 22, 2022
-
June 2022
- Jun 28, 2022 Biodiversity Treaty Increases Support for Rights of Mother Earth Jun 28, 2022
- Jun 11, 2022 Biodiversity Treaty Shows Renewed Support for the Rights of Nature Jun 11, 2022
- December 2021
-
October 2021
- Oct 12, 2021 Mujeres Kukama dicen que su río Marañón es un ser vivo: Demanda pionera presentada en Perú Oct 12, 2021
- Oct 12, 2021 Kukama Women Say Their Marañón River is a Living Being: Groundbreaking Lawsuit Filed in Peru Oct 12, 2021
-
September 2021
- Sep 20, 2021 Advocates at IUCN Congress Highlight a Wave of New Support for the Rights of Rivers Sep 20, 2021
- Sep 10, 2021 Rights of Nature a focus at the IUCN Congress Sep 10, 2021
-
February 2021
- Feb 12, 2021 EARTH LAW CENTER TO PARTNER ON “INVISIBLE HAND” YOUTH INTERNATIONAL SCREENING Feb 12, 2021
- Feb 8, 2021 EARTH LAW CENTER APPOINTS TWO NEW BOARD DIRECTORS Feb 8, 2021
-
September 2020
- Sep 25, 2020 Ceremony and Solidarity on 50th anniversary of orca's captivity Sep 25, 2020
- Sep 11, 2020 Coalition Submits Amicus Brief Urging Ecuador’s Constitutional Court to Make Landmark Rights of Nature Ruling in Los Cedros Case Sep 11, 2020
- Sep 2, 2020 Convention on Biodiversity Advances the Rights of Nature in Proposed Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework Sep 2, 2020
-
June 2020
- Jun 10, 2020 Earth Law Center joins the fight to free orca from 50 year captivity and bring her home. Jun 10, 2020
-
September 2019
- Sep 15, 2019 River Defenders Win Major Victory for California Waterways Sep 15, 2019
-
June 2019
- Jun 27, 2019 Pronunciamiento en El Salvador considera que los bosques son entidades vivientes Jun 27, 2019
- Jun 6, 2019 Pronouncement in El Salvador Deems Forests to be Living Entities Jun 6, 2019
-
May 2019
- May 23, 2019 Publisher Confirmed for First Earth Law Legal Textbook May 23, 2019
-
April 2019
- Apr 3, 2019 Environmental Leaders in El Salvador Announce Campaign to Give Legal Rights to Natural Forests Apr 3, 2019
- Apr 3, 2019 Earth Law Center Launches Community Toolkit for Rights of Nature Apr 3, 2019